Output list
1–10 of 27 results
Journal article
Waze to beat the system: a real-world evaluation of crowdsourced enforcement alerts on driver speed
First online publication 05-Oct-2026
Journal of Experimental Criminology, Advanced access
Objectives
Crowdsourced navigation applications such as Waze allow users to report speed enforcement locations in real time, alerting nearby drivers to the presence of police or speed cameras. Despite the widespread adoption of these platforms, limited research has examined whether enforcement alerts influence the speed of individual vehicles at an active enforcement site. This study addresses that gap using a real-world, quasi-experimental pre–post design to assess the impact of crowdsourced enforcement alerts on vehicle speed across multiple road environments in Queensland, Australia.
Methods
Vehicle speeds were measured using a ProLaser 4 speed detection device at 33 sites spanning various speed zones (40–100 km/h) and multiple road types including arterial, residential, commercial, highway, mixed, and active school zone environments. At each site, speeds were recorded during a baseline period before an enforcement alert appeared on Waze, and during a matched post-alert period of equal duration.
Results
Analysis of 9052 speed observations across 33 sites found a statistically significant reduction in speed relative to the posted limit following the appearance of enforcement alerts on the navigation apps (Before: M = 1.23 km/h, SD = 8.34; After: M = -3.92 km/h, SD = 7.77).
Conclusions
These findings highlight that crowdsourced enforcement alerts are a contemporary mechanism of technology-facilitated punishment avoidance and while suppressing speed at the point of detection, may erode the perceived certainty of apprehension and embolden offending across the wider road network over time. The practical implications of this study suggest that road policing in a digitally connected environment may benefit from shorter, more geographically dispersed deployments, with the appearance of an enforcement alert leveraged as a trigger to reposition enforcement, acting as a force multiplier for a finite enforcement resource.
Journal article
First online publication 10-Sep-2026
Journal of Criminology , Advanced access
Road crash fatalities that are caused by road rule violations are on the rise in numerous jurisdictions worldwide, despite recent efforts to prevent engagement in these behaviours via increased enforcement measures. In addition to traditional police enforcement and speed cameras, mobile phone and seatbelt detection cameras have also been introduced in various regions. However, technology also exists that can be used by drivers to notify them of traffic enforcement locations (e.g., social media pages and navigation applications such as Google Maps and Waze). This technology has the potential to circumvent the deterrent effect of traffic enforcement measures. As such, this study involved a cross-sectional survey to examine differences in offending behaviour, perceptions of being caught by police and by cameras, and experience with punishment avoidance between users and non-users of (1) social media pages and (2) navigation applications. The behaviours of focus included speeding, phone use while driving, and not wearing a seatbelt, as these behaviours are all captured by traffic cameras. A total of 2,237 drivers completed the survey with ages ranging between 17 and 90 years (Mage = 53.18, SD = 17.52). It was found that drivers who used both types of technology were significantly more likely to speed and use a handheld phone while driving, as well as experience punishment avoidance, compared to non-users. There were no significant differences in seatbelt use between users and non-users of the technology. Meanwhile, there were no significant differences for all behaviours in the perceptions of the certainty of being caught between users and non-users of the technology. These findings have system-wide implications that should be considered, including for enforcement, technology developers, policymakers, and drivers. Ultimately, the costs and benefits of allowing these features must be weighed, and innovative solutions (e.g., dynamic enforcement strategies) should be considered.
Journal article
First online publication 29-Jun-2026
Policing and Society, Advanced access
Roadside drug testing (RDT) is a key strategy in Australian road policing, yet little is known about public awareness of the drugs included in roadside testing programmes or how this awareness shapes deterrence, drug driving behaviour, and perceptions of police legitimacy. Following Queensland’s 2023 expansion of RDT to include cocaine, this exploratory study examined drivers’ knowledge of the substances screened at the roadside, and how deterrence perceptions, legitimacy views, and technology-driven punishment avoidance are associated with drug use and drug driving. A cross-sectional online survey of licenced Queensland drivers (N = 796) was recruited via social media, targeting drivers with a history of illicit drug use. Awareness of RDT was near universal (95.1%), yet only 48.7% correctly identified that cocaine is now screened, and only 25.8% correctly identified all current drugs tested for on the roadside. Aware drivers reported higher drug use and drug driving than unaware drivers, consistent with concentrated or direct enforcement exposure rather than successful general deterrence. Awareness showed no relationship with perceived certainty of apprehension. Lower views of Police Legitimacy (VPL) correlated with higher drug use, more frequent drug driving, and greater use of technology-based enforcement avoidance. A multivariate logistic regression among drug users found that direct punishment avoidance and perceived certainty of apprehension were the dominant predictors of drug driving, and VPL did not independently predict drug driving once these deterrence constructs were controlled. Collectively, findings underscore the importance of visible, credible enforcement and procedurally just road policing for shaping compliance within contemporary digital information environments.
Magazine article
What we discovered Speed camera alerts on navigation apps may be training drivers to speed
Published 2026
The Conversation, 27 October 2026
Navigation apps such as Waze, Google Maps and Apple Maps offer drivers many useful functions, but one of them is sometimes controversial: advance notice of police or speed cameras ahead.
In new research, my colleagues and I ran experiments to see how these alerts affect driver behaviour in the real world.
We found drivers slow down when they get a warning, which came as no surprise. But the more worrying part is what drivers do when the app stays quiet.
Journal article
Published 2026
Journal of Safety Research, 99, 72 - 81
Introduction: Speeding continues to be the largest contributor to road fatalities, with speed enforcement the primary countermeasure in place to prevent this behavior. Mobile average speed cameras have the potential to further prevent speeding behavior, as they are more unpredictable and can capture speeding along wider lengths of road. However, little is known about how drivers perceive these cameras, including deterrence related perceptions and perceptions of procedural justice. As such, this study aimed to examine the perceptions, attitudes, and concerns about mobile average speed camera enforcement methods, compared to other traditional methods (e.g., fixed spot speed cameras, mobile spot speed cameras, vehicle mounted mobile radar, and fixed average speed cameras). Method: A total of 887 respondents (M age = 42.8 years, SD = 17.7 years), completed a cross-sectional survey. Results: It was identified that mobile average speed enforcement occupied a middle ground in terms of deterrence perceptions compared to the other enforcement methods, yet they were viewed less favorably than fixed enforcement methods in terms of fairness, respect, and trustworthiness. Correlations, a linear regression and ANOVAs revealed the large role dysfunctional attitudes plays in intention to speed when there is mobile average speed enforcement. It was also found that respondents expressed reduced confidence in mobile average speed camera effectiveness across complex road environments, particularly among those holding stronger dysfunctional, pro-speeding attitudes. Conclusions: The results highlight that, in addition to deterrence capacity, perceived legitimacy and attitudes towards speeding can influence the effectiveness of mobile average speed enforcement. Practical Applications: The findings therefore suggest that transparent implementation, community engagement, and complementary behavioral interventions should also be considered to maximize road safety outcomes.
Journal article
Published 2026
Policing, 49, 5, 960 - 977
Purpose
This study explores how police vehicle design influences public perceptions of enforcement capability and driver behaviour. It addresses a gap in the literature on how specific visual elements shape perceived certainty of apprehension, certainty of punishment and the duration of deterrent effects.
Design/methodology/approach
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 40 Queensland-licensed drivers aged 18 years and older. Participants commented on the design elements that were most salient to them when it came to police vehicles. Participants also evaluated various police vehicle designs through open-ended questions and image-based rating tasks. A thematic analysis identified themes in perceptions around police vehicle designs and reported behavioural responses.
Findings
Participants consistently distinguished vehicles by visual cues, particularly the markings and bright colour of the vehicle impacted perceived deterrent effects. Traffic enforcement-focused vehicles, such as Highway Patrol cars and motorcycles, were seen as more deterrent than general duties (GD) vehicles, producing stronger immediate behaviour change and longer-lasting “halo effects”. Vehicle type, base vehicle colour, markings and visible equipment were described differently relative to perceptions of enforcement capability, the perceived role of that vehicle and associated behavioural responses.
Practical implications
The findings suggest that strategic police vehicle design serves as a force multiplier, enabling agencies to maximise deterrent impact with limited resources. Highly visible, purpose-designed traffic enforcement vehicles may yield greater road safety outcomes than deploying generic police vehicles.
Originality/value
This research provides a detailed examination of drivers' perception of police vehicle designs and the way in which such designs are associated with deterrence perceptions, offering evidence for consideration during vehicle procurement and deployment strategies to enhance road safety outcomes.
Journal article
Published 2026
Transportation Research. Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, 119, 1 - 12
This study investigates the application of procedural justice principles to police and AI-based camera enforcement of mobile phone use while driving. Utilizing a mixed-methods approach, two studies were conducted: qualitative interviews with 26 police officers and a quantitative survey of 292 drivers. The interviews explored officers' perceptions of fairness, respect, trustworthy motives, and voice during enforcement interactions, and compared this with their understanding of AI-Based enforcement. The survey compared drivers' perceptions of these procedural justice dimensions across police and camera enforcement. The interview results provided a unique perspective on how the procedural justice principles could be applied to experiences of police enforcement of phone use while driving, and also qualitatively compared police and camera enforcement for this offence. The survey results indicate that among drivers, police enforcement is perceived as significantly more procedurally just, particularly regarding listening, respect, and politeness, with effect sizes ranging from small to moderate. These findings suggest that the human element in police interactions plays a critical role in fostering public trust and perceived legitimacy, which may not be replicated by automated camera systems. The study highlights the need for careful consideration of procedural justice principles in the implementation of technological enforcement methods to ensure they complement, rather than undermine, established justice practices.
Journal article
Published 2026
Policing and Society, 36, 7, 913 - 927
This paper examines the experiences of young novice drivers and their parents who frequently drive across jurisdictional borders. Young novice drivers are overrepresented in vehicle crashes and resulting fatality statistics. Graduated Driver Licensing (GDL) schemes are countermeasures used in several international jurisdictions designed to reduce these crashes by incrementally increasing new drivers to more risky driving conditions as they gain experience. GDL schemes operate in all Australian states and territories; however, restrictions vary across jurisdictions. Regular road policing enforces GDL restrictions and is underpinned by the principles of deterrence theory, which proposes that individuals will be deterred from breaking rules and regulations due to the certainty, severity, and swiftness of punishment. Two studies were conducted in Australian border towns to explore this issue. The first study interviewed 16 parents of young drivers and 11 young drivers in the Australian Capital Territory. The second study conducted a small focus group, paired interviews or an interview with eight young drivers from a regional town on the Victorian/New South Wales border. The study found that accessing information regarding GDL restrictions, particularly outside of the state of licensure, poses major problems for young drivers and their parents. As a result, young drivers were not aware they were breaking cross-jurisdictional road rules, and deterrence theory was not as effective, suggesting that interventions based on alternative theoretical approaches, such as third-party policing, may have value.
Journal article
Published 2026
Policing and Society, 36, 3, 342 - 361
Police officers and camera-based enforcement systems are commonly used to enforce similar offences, yet there has been limited literature examining the differences in effectiveness of these enforcement types. As such, this study examined differences in deterrence, procedural justice and legitimacy perceptions between police and camera enforcement for speeding, as well as examined the unique effect of each enforcement method on speeding behaviour. A cross-sectional survey was administered to 2258 licensed drivers across four Australian states. The study compared perceptions of certainty, severity and swiftness of punishment as well as punishment avoidance, agreeance, fairness, trustworthy motives, and legitimacy across both enforcement types. Further, a series of 6 linear regressions were conducted to assess the unique impact of police and camera enforcement at three speeding offence ranges (1–10, 11–20, 20+ kmph over the limit). The results demonstrated drivers were more confident that camera-based systems would detect and sanction low and mid-range speeding, while police officers were viewed as more trustworthy, fairer, and legitimate. The use of camera enforcement deterred low-range speeding, while police officer enforcement did not significantly deter speeding of any range. Drivers who supported or agreed with the enforcement of speed limits reported lower offending rates. This study is the first to empirically compare the differential deterrent, procedural justice and legitimacy effects of police and camera-based speed enforcement. The findings highlight the need for a complementary enforcement strategy, integrating and leveraging the strengths of both methodologies to enhance driver deterrence and perceived legitimacy in enforcement efforts.
Journal article
Risky Driving and Enforcement Legitimacy on Queensland Beaches: A Study of Offending and Legitimacy
Published 2025
Journal of Road Safety, 36, 2, 23 - 36
This study investigated the relationship between self-reported offending behaviours of drivers and their views of enforcement legitimacy on Queensland beaches. Despite the growing interest in beach driving offending due to many serious injury and fatal crashes, limited research contrasts self-reported offending in beach versus road environments. This study builds on previous research on beach offending by examining drivers’ views of legitimacy regarding rangers and police and their self-reported offending in both driving environments. Two main objectives guided this research: firstly, to examine and contrast self-reported offending of drivers in beach and road locations; secondly, to determine if lower views of legitimacy in police or rangers correlated with higher offending rates in either environment. In total, 702 participants completed the survey and provided demographic data, driving experience, compliance with road rules, and views of legitimacy regarding enforcement agencies. Key findings identified statistically significant differences in behaviour by location. Higher rates of offending on roads compared to beaches were reported for speeding and drink driving while higher rates of offending on beaches were reported for seatbelts (i.e., non-use). Chi-square analysis revealed a significant relationship between views of legitimacy and offending behaviour, suggesting that higher views of the legitimacy of enforcement agencies is significantly associated with lower offending rates. These findings underscore the potential impact of enhancing views of legitimacy through community policing strategies to improve compliance with the road rules and overall road safety on beaches. The study highlights the need for targeted enforcement and education efforts to address unique challenges related to driving in beach environments.