"You Can't Be Too Skinny. You Can't Be Too Fat. I Don't Know What You Are Supposed To Be.": A qualitative focus group study exploring body image experiences of South Asian women in the UK
Ankita Mishra, Nadia Craddock, Jamie Chan, Rosiel Elwyn, Silvia Cerea, Wen Q Tan, Haifa Bin Haamed and Fidan Turk
Appearance concerns Body Image Focus Groups Intersectionality Reflexive Thematic Analysis South Asian women Culture Women Bicultural Acculturation Other Collaborations Thompson Institute Special Collection UniSC Diversity Area - Cultural and Linguistic Diversity
British South Asian women may experience unique appearance pressures associated with their intersecting (racialised and gendered) identities; yet qualitative investigations of intersectional understanding of their body image is scarce. The aim of this study was to explore sociocultural factors influencing British South Asian women’s body image using an intersectional framework. Seven focus groups were conducted with 22 women of South Asian heritage living in the UK between the age of 18 and 48 years old who were comfortable speaking in English. Data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. We generated four themes (1) navigating (often marriage-related) appearance pressures from South Asian elders and aunties (2) negotiating cultural and societal standards across different aspects of one’s identity (3) representation of South Asian women in the wider context and (4) forms of healing from the pressures imposed on South Asian women. The findings have important implications for appearance experiences of South Asian women by acknowledging the need for tailored and nuanced responses to their complex needs in the sociocultural, political and relational context such as family, peers, education, health, media and the wider consumer landscape.
•A qualitative study exploring body image experiences of South Asian women in the UK.•Women experienced appearance pressure from older generations (i.e., marriageability).•Body image was influenced by competing aspects of intersecting identities.•Participants lamented the lack of representation of South Asian women in the media.•Focus groups acted as sites of resistance and solidarity against appearance pressures.
Details
Title
"You Can't Be Too Skinny. You Can't Be Too Fat. I Don't Know What You Are Supposed To Be.": A qualitative focus group study exploring body image experiences of South Asian women in the UK
Authors
Ankita Mishra (Corresponding Author) - University of Sheffield
Nadia Craddock (Author) - University of the West of England
Jamie Chan (Author) - University of Sussex
Rosiel Elwyn (Author) - University of the Sunshine Coast, Queensland, Thompson Institute
Silvia Cerea (Author) - University of Padua
Wen Q Tan (Author) - University of Sheffield
Haifa Bin Haamed (Author) - University of Sheffield
Fidan Turk (Author) - University of Sheffield
Publication details
Body Image, Vol.46, pp.123-138
Publisher
Elsevier BV
Date published
2023
DOI
10.1016/j.bodyim.2023.05.005
ISSN
1873-6807; 1740-1445
Copyright note
(c) The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Organisation Unit
School of Health - Nursing; Thompson Institute; School of Law and Society; External