Logo image
Back
Recognition and assessment of error in geographic information systems
Journal article   Peer reviewed

Recognition and assessment of error in geographic information systems

Stephen J Walsh, D R Lightfoot and D R Butler
Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, Vol.53(10), pp.1423-1430
1987
url
http://eserv.asprs.org/PERS/1987journal/oct/1987_oct_1423-1430.pdfView
Webpage

Abstract

Geomatic Engineering
Computer-generated maps, manipulated through geographic information systems (GIS), are powerful tools for analyzing complex spatial interactions. Depending upon the level of error inherent in the source data and the error operationally produced through data capture and manipulation, GIS products may possess significant amounts of error. Errors inherent in (1) land-cover maps derived through classification of Landsat digital data; (2) slope-angle and slope aspect information derived from digital terrain tapes; and (3) soil-type data acquired from USDA Soil Conservation Service (SCS) soil survey reports were assessed. These data were compared to field information collected for 35 sample sites distributed throughout a four-square-mile test area. A 2.5-acre (IOO sqm) and IO.O-acre (200 sqm) resolution cell were utilized to capture data using both the cell midpoint and cell-dominant methods of encoding. Inherent error ranged from 43 percent for the 2.5-acre (100 sqm) land-cover map to 83 percent for the IO.O-acre (200 sqm) slope-angle map. Operational error was also examined. When two or more data layers were combined, errors were found to range from 13 to 29 percent. Combined inherent and operational error ranged from 71 to 83 percent. Smaller cell sizes produced lower inherent and operational error levels, as did the use of the cell dominant area method of data capture. Error significantly increased when more than two data layers were analyzed in concert.

Details

Metrics

779 Record Views
Logo image