Beyond fixes that fail: identifying sustainable improvements to tree seed supply and farmer participation in forest and landscape restoration

Michel Valette; Barbara Vinceti; Nestor Gregorio; Arwen Bailey; Evert Thomas; Riina Jalonen

doi:10.5751/ES-12032-250430

Back

Beyond fixes that fail: identifying sustainable improvements to tree seed supply and farmer participation in forest and landscape restoration

Journal article

Open access

Peer reviewed

Beyond fixes that fail: identifying sustainable improvements to tree seed supply and farmer participation in forest and landscape restoration

Michel Valette, Barbara Vinceti, Nestor Gregorio, Arwen Bailey, Evert Thomas and Riina Jalonen

Ecology and Society, Vol.25(4), 30

2020

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-12032-250430

Files and links (2)

pdf

Beyond fixes that fail_ identifying sustainable improvements to tree seed supply and farmer participation in forest and landscape restoration2.40 MBDownload View

Published VersionCC BY-NC V4.0, Open Access

url

https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-12032-250430View

Published Version

Abstract

forest landscape restoration

genetic diversity

smallholder involvement

system archetypes

system dynamics

Growing evidence suggests that constraints to the availability and quality of tree seed can undermine the success of forest and landscape restoration efforts and the delivery of associated benefits such as mitigating climate change and halting biodiversity loss. Past experiences to promote tree seed supply have frequently shown limited outcomes over time, partly because of unexpected, deleterious dynamics that emerged from the interventions themselves. In this study, we used a dynamic system approach to understand the interrelated problems that constrain the supply of good quality and site-adapted tree seeds to meet smallholders’ and other stakeholders’ demand in Burkina Faso and the Philippines, and to identify leverage points for intervention. Causal loop diagrams were constructed for each country, based on a framework of indicators of effective tree seed supply systems, literature review, semistructured interviews, and expert validation. The diagrams illustrate the complex interactions between planned interventions and their expected and unexpected effects that frequently lead to adverse outcomes. For example, the high turnover of forestry officers in municipalities to combat corruption in Burkina Faso combined with limited resources to support smallholders undermined the officers’ ability to strengthen local capacities in seedling production and sustainable forest management. In the Philippines, the imposition of rigid requirements for seedling survival rates as a condition for funding, in the absence of adequate time and resources for the production of quality seedlings and monitoring, resulted in exaggerated survival rates during reporting, which in turn hampered the detection and addressing of shortcomings. A dynamic system approach can help stakeholders recognize the broader impacts of their actions and jointly identify appropriate interventions, from developing more context-specific approaches to reconsidering investment criteria to balance benefits.

Details

Title: Beyond fixes that fail: identifying sustainable improvements to tree seed supply and farmer participation in forest and landscape restoration
Authors: Michel Valette (Author) - Imperial College London
Barbara Vinceti (Author) - Alliance Bioversity International - CIAT
Nestor Gregorio (Author) - University of the Sunshine Coast, Queensland, Tropical Forests and People Research Centre
Arwen Bailey (Author) - Alliance Bioversity International - CIAT
Evert Thomas (Author) - Alliance Bioversity International - CIAT
Riina Jalonen (Author) - Alliance Bioversity International - CIAT
Publication details: Ecology and Society, Vol.25(4), 30
Publisher: Resilience Alliance Publications
Date published: 2020
DOI: 10.5751/ES-12032-250430
ISSN: 1708-3087
Copyright note: Copyright © 2020 by the author(s). Published here under license by The Resilience Alliance. This article is under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. You may share and adapt the work for noncommercial purposes provided the original author and source are credited, you indicate whether any changes were made, and you include a link to the license.
Organisation Unit: Tropical Forests and People Research Centre; University of the Sunshine Coast, Queensland; Forest Research Institute
Language: English
Record Identifier: 99492808602621
Output Type: Journal article